<< To the contents of the issue

Journal	Methodology and History of Psychology	Year	2018	Issue	2	Pages	22–32
Section	The Anniversary of A. V. Brushlinsky	Type	Scientific article	DOI	10.7868/S1819265318020024
Citation	Nyagolova M. D. (2018). Vklad A. V. Brušlinskogo v kritiku kul'turno‑istoričeskoj teorii myšleniâ [A. V. Brushlinsky's contribution to criticism of cultural‑historical theory of thinking] // Metodologiâ i istoriâ psihologii. Iss. 2. P. 22–32.

The article is devoted to A. V. Brushlinsky's scientific creative work. The methodological and historical‑psychological value of his first scientific monograph "Cultural‑Historical Theory of Thinking" (1968) is considered. Publications for the last ten years tracing A. V. Brushlinsky's contribution to studying L. S. Vygotsky's creative work are presented and briefly commented. The orientation of his main conclusions is analyzed. The reasons of the lack of scientific discussions between representatives and followers of L. S. Vygotsky's school in the 1960s are discussed. It is shown that the beginning of discussions on the principles of the cultural‑historical theory of thinking, in the Russian and international terms, happens only in 1990s. As a result, it is noted that throughout the life, A. V. Brushlinsky consistently studied and developed the criticism of the cultural‑historical theory of thinking.

Keywords: cultural‑historical theory of thinking; subject‑activity approach; sign‑oriented theory; social‑oriented theory; interiorization; psyche; theory of highest psychological functions; zone of proximal development; Soviet psychology; A. V. Brushlinsky; L. S. Vygotsky; "the Khrushchev's thaw"; history of scientific ideas

• A. V. Brušlinskomu 60 let [A. V. Brushlinsky is 60 years old] (1993) // Voprosy psihologii. N 1. P. 116–119.
• Abulkhanova K. A., Volovikova M. I. (2003). O naučnom nasledii A. V. Brušlinskogo [On the scientific heritage of A. V. Brushlinsky] // Psihologiâ: sovremennye napravleniâ meždisciplinarnyh issledovanij / Ed. by A. L. Zhuravlev, N. V. Tarabrina. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. P. 23–28.
• Artamonov V. I. (1994). Diskussii. L. S. Vygotskij i marksizm v sovetskoj psihologii [Discussions. L. S. Vygotsky and Marxism in Soviet psychology] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 1. P. 115–126.
• Bogdanchikov S. A. (2008). Sovetskaâ psihologiâ nakanune 1936 goda [Soviet psychology on the eve of 1936] // Voprosy psihologii. N 1. P. 156–164.
• Bogdanchikov S. A. (2011). Istoriâ sovetskoj psihologii: 1920–1930-e gody [History of Soviet Psychology: 1920–1930s] // Saratov: Saratovskij gosudarstvennyj social'no‑èkonomičeskij universitet.
• Bogdanchikov S. A. (2013). O vklade A. V. Brušlinskogo v izučenie istorii sovetskoj psihologii [On the contribution of A. V. Brushlinsky to the study of the history of Soviet psychology] // Čelovek, subʺekt, ličnost' v sovremennoj psihologii. Vol. 1 / Ed. by A. L. Zhuravlev, E. A. Sergienko. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. P. 24–26.
• Bruschlinski A. W. (1967). Die "kulturhistorische Theorie" des Denkens // Budilowa et al. Untersuchungen des Denkens in der sowjetischen Psychologie. Berlin: Volk und Wissen.
• Brushlinsky A. (2013). Psihologiâ na subekta [Psychology of the Subject, in Bulgarian]. Veliko Tarnovo: PIK.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (1966). "Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ" teoriâ myšleniâ ["Cultural‑historical" theory of thinking] // Issledovaniâ myšleniâ v sovetskoj psihologii / Ed. by E. V. Shorokhova. Moscow: Nauka. P. 123–174.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (1968). Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ teoriâ myšleniâ [Cultural‑Historical Theory of Thinking]. Moscow: Vysšaâ škola.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (1981). Problema obŝestvennogo‑individual'nogo v psihike čeloveka i kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ teoriâ [The problem of the social and individual in the human psyche and cultural‑historical theory] // Naučnoe tvorčestvo L. S. Vygotskogo i sovremennaâ psihologiâ. Tezisy dokladov Vsesoûznoj konferencii, Moskva, 23–25 iûnâ 1981 g. [Scientific Work of L. S. Vygotsky and Modern Psychology. Abstracts of the All‑Union Conference, Moscow, June 23–25, 1981] / Ed. by V. V. Davydov. Moscow: VNIITÈ. P. 32–37.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (1989). S. L. Rubinštejn – rodonačal'nik deâtel'nostnogo podhoda v psihologičeskoj nauke [S. L. Rubinstein as the founder of the activity approach in psychological science] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 3. P. 43–59.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (1996). Pervye utočneniâ tekstov L. S. Vygotskogo [The first clarification of L. S. Vygotsky's texts] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 3. P. 19–25.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (2003). Psihologiâ subʺekta [Psychology of the Subject]. Saint Petersburg: Aletejâ.
• Brushlinsky A. V. (2010). Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ teoriâ myšleniâ [Cultural‑Historical Theory of Thinking]. Moscow: LIBROKOM.
• Davydov V. V. (1991). L. S. Vygotskij i problemy pedagogičeskoj psihologii [L. S. Vygotsky and problems of educational psychology] // L. S. Vygotsky. Pedagogičeskaâ psihologiâ [Educational Psychology]. Moscow: Pedagogika. P. 5–32.
• Deâtel'nost': teorii, metodologiâ, problemy [Activity: Theory, Methodology, Problems] (1990) / Ed. by I. T. Kasavin. Moscow: Politizdat.
• Graham L. R. (1991). Estestvoznanie, filosofiâ i nauki o čelovečeskom povedenii v Sovetskom Soûze [Science, Philosophy, and Human Behavior in the Soviet Union]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo političeskoj literatury.
• Keiler P. (2012). "Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ teoriâ" i "kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ škola": ot mifa (obratno) k real'nosti ["Cultural‑historical theory" and "Cultural‑historical school": From myth (back) to reality] // Psihologičeskij žurnal Meždunarodnogo universiteta prirody, obŝestva i čeloveka "Dubna." N 1. P. 34–46.
• Kudryavtsev V. T. (2013). A. V. Brušlinskij: kritika "znakocentrizma" i ee kontekst [A. V. Brushlinsky: criticism of "sign‑centeredism" and its context] // Čelovek, subʺekt, ličnost' v sovremennoj psihologii. Vol. 1 / Ed. by A. L. Zhuravlev, E. A. Sergienko. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. P. 32–35.
• Mikhailov F. T. (2005). Problemy metoda kul'turno‑istoričeskoj psihologii [Problems of the method of cultural‑historical psychology] // Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ psihologiâ. N 2. P. 30–46.
• Nakumura K. (1996). Vokrug tolkovaniâ ponâtiâ zony bližajšego razvitiâ [Around the interpretation of the concept of the zone of proximal development] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 4. P. 20–31.
• Nyagolova M. (2006). Humanističnata psihologiâ [Humanistic Psychology, in Bulgarian]. Veliko Tarnovo: Universitetsko izdatelstvo «Sv. Sv. Kiril i Metodij».
• Paradoksy našego vremeni (interv'û s A. V. Brušlinskim) [Paradoxes of our time (interview with A. V. Brushlinsky)] (1995) // Mir psihologii i psihologiâ v mire. N 4. P. 100–117.
• Paschenko E. V. (1997). Vygotskij, Rubinštejn i Moskoviči [Vygotsky, Rubinstein and Moscovici] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 2. P. 169–174.
• Psihologičeskaâ nauka v Rossii XX stoletiâ [Psychological Science in Russia of the 20th Century: Problems of Theory and History] (1997) / Ed. by A. V. Brushlinsky. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN.
• Rozin V. M. (1997). Issledovanie myšleniâ v rabote L. S. Vygotskogo "Myšlenie i reč'" [The study of thinking in L. S. Vygotsky's work "Thinking and Speech"] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 5. P. 128–138.
• Selivanov V. V. (2010). Predislovie [Foreword] // A. V. Brushlinsky. Kul'turno‑istoričeskaâ teoriâ myšleniâ [Cultural‑Historical Theory of Thinking]. Moscow: LIBROKOM. P. 4–20.
• Sirotkina I. E. (1996). Nauki o čeloveke v istoričeskoj perspektive: dialog meždu Rossiej i Zapadom vokrug rabot M. M. Bahtina, L. S. Vygotskogo i S. L. Rubinštejna [The science of man in a historical perspective: a dialogue between Russia and the West around the works of M. M. Bakhtin, L. S. Vygotsky, and S. L. Rubinstein] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 2. P. 183–186.
• Slutsky V. (2000). Book Review: Russian Psychology of the 20th century (Problems, Theories and Histories) // International Journal of Behavioral Development. 24 (2).
• Vygotsky L. S. (1956). Izbrannye psihologičeskie issledovaniâ [Selected Psychological Studies]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Akademii pedagogičeskih nauk.
• Vygotsky L. S. (1960). Razvitie vysših psihičeskih funkcij [The Development of Higher Mental Functions]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Akademii pedagogičeskih nauk.
• Vygotsky L. S. (1982). Sobranie sočinenij. T. 2. Problemy obŝej psihologii [Collected Works. Vol. 2. Problems of General Psychology]. Moscow: Pedagogika.
• Vygotsky L. S. (1983). Sobranie sočinenij. T. 3. Problemy razvitiâ psihiki [Collected Works. Vol. 3. Problems of Mental Development]. Moscow: Pedagogika.
• Vygotsky L. S. (1991). Pedagogičeskaâ psihologiâ [Educational Psychology]. Moscow: Pedagogika.
• Yaroshevsky M. G. (1992). L. S. Vygotskij i marksizm v sovetskoj psihologii [L. S. Vygotsky and Marxism in Soviet psychology] // Psihologičeskij žurnal. N 5. P. 84–99.
• Zhdan A. N. (2013). Vklad A. V. Brušlinskogo v istoriko‑psihologičeskuû nauku [The contribution of A. V. Brushlinsky to the study of the history of psychology] // Čelovek, subʺekt, ličnost' v sovremennoj psihologii. Vol. 1 / Ed. by A. L. Zhuravlev, E. A. Sergienko. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. P. 26–29.
• Znakov V. V. (2003). A. V. Brušlinskij: vernost' tradiciâm i èvolûciâ naučnyh vzglâdov [A. V. Brushlinsky: loyalty to traditions and the evolution of scientific views] // Tvorčeskoe nasledie A. V. Brušlinskogo i O. K. Tihomirova i sovremennaâ psihologiâ myšleniâ / Ed. by V. V. Znakov, T. V. Kornilova. Moscow: Institut psihologii RAN. P. 17–24.